Made in: Japan
Here we have three versions of the original Palomino Blackwing pencils, all out of production. These have the “Soft and Smooth Graphite Formulation.”
• First edition (circa 2010): Pony logo with gold band
• Second edition: Pony logo without the gold band
• Third edition: Trees logo
I would say the second edition is the most rare, simply because they were only produced for a short amount of time. NOTE: The Second Edition without the gold band is available for purchase here.
Palomino Brands was at one time a division of California Cedar Products Company, which produces CalCedar® and other types of wood slats for pencil manufacturers around the world. California Republic Stationer pencils were first produced beginning in 2003, and in 2012 the company began a transition to Palomino Brands for all new production.
Today, the company no longer uses the Palomino brand name, and instead has put all of its chips on Black(wing). Every three months a new Blackwing Volumes limited edition pencil is introduced, which are made at an undisclosed location in Japan using California cedar and Japanese graphite cores.